Lawfare Beat March 17

While black bloc anarchists under the antifa banner continue to attack the federal courthouse and other symbols of authority in Portland their allies in authority and establishment activism assist through lawfare, filing lawsuits and amicus briefs that seek to limit the tactics law enforcement can use for riot control.

Mayor and police commissioner Ted Wheeler has been desperately trying to finally put a stop to the anarchists’ campaign by allowing a more aggressive police response to riots. Recently antifa set upon a favorite target, the Pearl District, to break stuff and assail an apartment building, likely in response to a neighborhood group organizing to oppose them. The police responded by “kettling” –corralling–them and demanding protesters allow themselves to be photographed or be arrested. In January federal judges found the practice legal in denying two ACLU civil suits to ban the practice.

The Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR) has allied with the ACLU and others in leading the legal arm of the anarchist campaign. One founder of Oregon CAIR is a prominent and vociferous police abolition advocate. On March 13 they combined with the Oregon Justice Resource Center to demand Portland Police refrain from kettling, invoking the sainted Breonna Taylor, who they claim was murdered in her sleep:

PORTLAND, Ore.—Today leaders from the Oregon Justice Resource Center, CAIR-Oregon, and the American Civil Liberties Union of Oregon released a statement on the Portland Police Bureau following the mass detention and arrest of protesters last night.

“Today, we wake up one year ago from the day when Breonna Taylor was killed by police officers while she was sleeping peacefully in her own bed in her own home. Officers still have not been held accountable for killing her. Breonna Taylor should be alive today.

“And today Portland wakes up again to an unaccountable Portland Police Bureau (PPB) who last night detained an entire city block of people for protesting on their own streets in their own city — and then, without lawful basis, required individuals to take off their COVID-19 protective face masks, be photographed, and to show identification before being permitted to leave. 

“Police killings, police assaults, and police states must end, and we must continue to declare that Black lives matter until our government actions reflect that truth.

“Under the authority of Mayor and Police Commissioner Ted Wheeler and Police Chief Chuck Lovell, what PPB did last night — kettling — is an aggressive and indiscriminate police tactic of surrounding and boxing in a group of people and blocking off all exit points. Both the Oregon Justice Resource Center and ACLU of Oregon are currently representing clients in federal lawsuits against PPB’s use of the kettling tactic against anti-Trump protesters in 2017. In neither case has the court approved of or found constitutional this abusive tactic. While the courts determined qualified immunity shielded officers from accountability for their actions in 2017, the court did not greenlight the tactic for use. 

I believe they’re referring to the kettling I was caught up in at Portland’s Inauguration Day rioting, when they arrested about a hundred, keeping us overnight in the drunk tank. The coalition reminds the city they have an ally in Multnomah District Attorney Mike Schmidt, who rivals his buddy San Francisco DA Chesa Boudin in progressive zeal, before invoking without naming Andy Ngo, who routinely publishes publicly available mugshots, which antifa breathlessly describes as “providing Atomwaffen with kill lists.”

“That PPB officers also continue to violate Oregon law and invade the constitutional right to privacy — by collecting photographs and identification of those protesting the police — underscores that PPB aims to intimidate and chill the rights of our community members and local and independent press. It is clearly understood by PPB that the elected district attorney will not prosecute individuals arrested and charged for an alleged offense that is not supported by the evidence, nor will the district attorney prosecute where PPB attempted to curtail First Amendment rights. It is also clearly understood by PPB that the personal identifiable information collected by them is often quickly made public and then is used by far-right groups and personalities to doxx, harass, and intimidate protestors. Historically, this tactic by PPB has been used exclusively against progressive and left-leaning protestors, consistent with their bias as reflected in their lax enforcement towards violent and hateful far-right groups and militias. 

“[V]iolent and hateful far-right groups and militias” have never engaged in the sort of rioting antifa perpetuates, of course. Their violence has consisted entirely of provoking antifa to violence by their mere presence on the street, with the intention of exposing them.

But in our environment of leftist narrative control the melees that arose from these encounters has only served to lend plausibility (in the eyes of the credulous) to the left’s claim the city is routinely under attack by fascists. It’s safe to say the naïve patriot groups’ strategy to provoke and expose antifa violence (very much like antifa’s strategy to provoke and document police violence) has failed utterly; like everything else it’s been fed into the media narrate-o-matic and come out as palatable gruel for the credulous. It’s nice to hold the Megaphone.

The progress of the cycle, rightwing provocation producing leftwing violence, which has been ongoing since Trump’s presidential campaign, only served to ultimately draw the rightwingers into the one lurid and sensational act of their own violence, the storming of the Capitol on January 6. That incident–and I’ve seen no one suggest this though it seems obvious–was only possible because of the months-long insurrection antifa initiated with the Summer of Soros. The naïve patriot groups were emulating the escalated tactics of the left, and competing with them. At the end of the day they were hoisted by their own petard, provoked into doing something stupid which was then documented by their enemies and is now being used to shut them, and us, down.

The letter invokes black body privilege, of course:

“Law enforcement agencies — from police departments to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) — continue to brutalize Black and Brown bodies with impunity and no accountability. So, people of all backgrounds and races continue to assemble together to demand justice. In these calls for action, it is not lost on our communities that police continue to use militarized weapons that are harming the environment and causing the physical destruction of property in Portland, oftentimes in BIPOC or lower-income communities.

“Brown” is now capitalized, apparently. The letter itself is the documentary part of the left’s provoke violence/document violence strategy against police and authority, and with an ally in the US Department of Justice now, is chilling:

“What is PPB’s response when our community demands safety and justice? They repeatedly engage in violent and unconstitutional tactics that morally compel the community to respond — through protest, mutual aid, legal action, and legislation. It is clear that our public funds and resources must be reallocated away from failed law enforcement practices and spent on the community and programs that actually keep the public safe. 

“PPB officers commit violence and break the law again and again at lawful protests because they know the mayor, the police chief, and the City of Portland will not hold them accountable, by PPB disciplinary processes or by shifting resources, even though the lack of accountability keeps the public unsafe. If Mayor Ted Wheeler, even with his direct oversight over the PPB as police commissioner, will not act, then other federal, state, local and community leaders must do so. 

“First, we request that U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland investigate the ongoing civil rights abuses that local and federal law enforcement are committing in Portland. Second, we call on all Oregon state legislators and Multnomah County elected and public officials to fully and unequivocally support the legislative reforms on policing forwarded by the BIPOC Caucus of the Oregon Legislature, which aim to provide greater oversight, transparency, and accountability of law enforcement agencies in Oregon.

“Law enforcement traumatization of our community must be stopped.” 

We’ll see now if the nation’s highest law enforcement official joins in with anarchism. Interesting times.


“Joker, we have a new directive from MSNBC on black and brown…also, it’s black ‘bodies’ not people…”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: